You're right Pax, but he isn't all wrong either. The fifties were not the "Golden Age of Catholicism" but objectively speaking they were better than the NO or the Trads are now. Being gone for over thirty years I can tell you something is missing in each camp, both are way too over intellectualized. Forgive me Bishop Williamson, but you're English, anyway. If one must be an Aristotlian and a Church Historian while being conversant with everything written since say Trent, then this is not a religion of Jesus, but the University. I see everywhere the refutation of the Holy Ghost and faith and infused knowledge. The attitude is philology first and listening maybe later. The NO to the exclusion of what came before and the Trads to the exclusion of everything since. Pax Vobiscum indeed!