FishEaters Traditional Catholic Forums

Full Version: Our own version of the Fr. Z poll (bis)
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
QuisUtDeus,
This poll is too binary: Yes or No are the only options given.
My true opinion was: Yes, it is valid, but flawed.

Same as if one would launch a poll with that question: Was the Consecration (of Russia) performed by JPII in 1984 valid? Yes or No.
Fairly speaking one cannot it was invalid although it was 90% flawed with respect to our Lady's requirements.

It's supposed to be binary, that's the point. Your answer would be "yes".
Yes.
OK,
Another poll:
Do you like eating spinachs and would you like to eat them at every meal 7/7, 365/365

Reply only by yes or no.
OK
Another poll.
Reply only by yes or no:
Do you like eating spinachs and would like eating them at every meal, 7/7, 365/365 ?
(03-02-2011, 04:09 PM)maso Wrote: [ -> ]OK
Another poll.
Reply only by yes or no:
Do you like eating spinachs and would like eating them at every meal, 7/7, 365/365 ?

No.
A more accurate parallel poll would be: do you believe spinach is a vegetable yes/no
(03-02-2011, 05:40 PM)Bakuryokuso Wrote: [ -> ]A more accurate parallel poll would be: do you believe spinach is a vegetable yes/no

No.  It is an evil plant from Satan's garden!  :P  :laughing:
(03-02-2011, 01:04 PM)maso Wrote: [ -> ]QuisUtDeus,
This poll is too binary: Yes or No are the only options given.
My true opinion was: Yes, it is valid, but flawed.

Same as if one would launch a poll with that question: Was the Consecration (of Russia) performed by JPII in 1984 valid? Yes or No.
Fairly speaking one cannot it was invalid although it was 90% flawed with respect to our Lady's requirements.

What are Mary's requirements?
(03-02-2011, 08:31 PM)Lydia Grace Wrote: [ -> ]
(03-02-2011, 01:04 PM)maso Wrote: [ -> ]QuisUtDeus,
This poll is too binary: Yes or No are the only options given.
My true opinion was: Yes, it is valid, but flawed.

Same as if one would launch a poll with that question: Was the Consecration (of Russia) performed by JPII in 1984 valid? Yes or No.
Fairly speaking one cannot it was invalid although it was 90% flawed with respect to our Lady's requirements.

What are Mary's requirements?

The Pope was supposed specifically consecrate Russia in concert with all the world's bishops so I'd say it wasn't valid. Consecration has not been performed.