FishEaters Traditional Catholic Forums

Has anyone ever managed to read this book? I have a copy sitting on my bookshelf that I bought a while back but I have not managed to read it. I have heard many trads reccomend this book but I have heard others who have said that it is very unbalanced and uncharitable. For those who have actually read this book how accurate and balanced is it?

Why don't you read it and tell us what you think?

It's a very good truthful book, read it.

I read it years ago and it is excellent and I highly recommend it.

No I haven't but I notice there is a second edition out just this september.