FishEaters Traditional Catholic Forums
Do Trads agree about anything? - Printable Version

+- FishEaters Traditional Catholic Forums (https://www.fisheaters.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Church (https://www.fisheaters.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Forum: Catholicism (https://www.fisheaters.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Thread: Do Trads agree about anything? (/showthread.php?tid=46856)

Pages: 1 2


Do Trads agree about anything? - dedalus28 - 07-10-2011

http://truerestoration.blogspot.com/2011/07/do-traditional-catholics-agree-about.html


Re: Do Trads agree about anything? - Someone1776 - 07-10-2011

Forum rules ask you to at least summarize the article although posting the article is full is better. 


Re: Do Trads agree about anything? - Someone1776 - 07-10-2011

That article does bring up a good point that trads disagree on a lot. But, it greatly exaggerates the differences between the SSPX and  Diocesan Trads.

However, I think 99% of trads will agree that the NO is inferior when compared to the TLM and that the Church has not headed in the best direction these past 40 years. 


Re: Do Trads agree about anything? - WhollyRoaminCatholic - 07-10-2011

(07-10-2011, 10:12 PM)Someone1776 Wrote: Forum rules ask you to at least summarize the article although posting the article is full is better. 

I agree with that.


Re: Do Trads agree about anything? - Scipio_a - 07-10-2011

"The New Mass is “defective”


Indult/Motu: No.  The Extraordinary Form of the Mass is extended to the faithful by a gracious permission of the Holy Father.  If one day he chooses to remove that permission, we will obey rather than put ourselves outside the body of the Church.
"


This is wrong...perhaps some it applies to but the vast majority would say yes....And many of those would probably move on to the SSPX etc if the dioc refused Mass...now some of the newer folks the just popped over from an NO to see what's p might not....but some of them will as well...


Trads, by definition agree that the TLM is objectively superior....this is by definition.


Additionally they have a Catholic sense that is in agreement even when they display very loud disagreements about implementation...

There are underlying assuptions about the world that make discussing topics with trads easier than with other people.


It's like being married for a few years or being so like minded that you only have to say a couple of words for the other person to fill in the rest....anyway...don't think I'll make it farther in the article...since I already know trads disagree about stuff.


Re: Do Trads agree about anything? - dedalus28 - 07-10-2011

Lol, I was just about to post it.  Thanks scipio.


Re: Do Trads agree about anything? - CrusaderKing - 07-10-2011

One thing Trads do agree on, whether they attend a Diocesan TLM, FSSP, ICK, IGS, SSPX, Independent Chapel, SSPV, CMRI, or even the "home aloners" is that they want this nightmare of the last 4-5 decades to end and Tradition to be restored to its rightful place.


Re: Do Trads agree about anything? - The_Harlequin_King - 07-10-2011

Ha, indeed.

One thing, though, is that every trad I've talked to for a while has ultimately agreed that the minor orders ought to be restored. So, that's something.


Re: Do Trads agree about anything? - Unum Sint - 07-10-2011

(07-10-2011, 10:32 PM)CrusaderKing Wrote: One thing Trads do agree on, whether they attend a Diocesan TLM, FSSP, ICK, IGS, SSPX, Independent Chapel, SSPV, CMRI, or even the "home aloners" is that they want this nightmare of the last 4-5 decades to end and Tradition to be restored to its rightful place.

Ditto to that.


Re: Do Trads agree about anything? - Augstine Baker - 07-10-2011

Where the Charity and Truth come into play, real Traditionalists don't disagree.  There are some things that men of good will can disagree upon.