FishEaters Traditional Catholic Forums
The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - Printable Version

+- FishEaters Traditional Catholic Forums (https://www.fisheaters.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Church (https://www.fisheaters.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Forum: Catholicism (https://www.fisheaters.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Thread: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 (/showthread.php?tid=47423)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - Thomas Patron - 07-27-2011

[Image: milagre2011%2528fatima2011.blogs.sapo.pt%2529.JPG]




Re: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - Pheo - 07-27-2011

Uhhh, isn't that just a Sun Halo?

I just saw one here in Ontario a couple weeks ago...

[Image: 230px-Sun_halo_optical_phenomenon_edit.jpg]

[Image: 230px-Halo_padang.jpg]

[Image: 250px-Solar-halo-inca-trail-20080928.jpg]

Etc.
God forgive me if I'm off on this one, but those happen pretty frequently.  Maybe just not in Portugal?...???


Re: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - Thomas Patron - 07-27-2011

(07-27-2011, 04:15 PM)Pheo Wrote: Uhhh, isn't that just a Sun Halo?

I just saw one here in Ontario a couple weeks ago...

[Image: 230px-Sun_halo_optical_phenomenon_edit.jpg]

[Image: 230px-Halo_padang.jpg]

[Image: 250px-Solar-halo-inca-trail-20080928.jpg]

Etc.
God forgive me if I'm off on this one, but those happen pretty frequently.  Maybe just not in Portugal?...???

That's false, actually most photos of sun halos are photoshops. But this was witnessed by  200.000 people.


Re: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - Pheo - 07-27-2011

(07-27-2011, 04:20 PM)Thomas Patron Wrote: That's false, actually most photos of sun halos are photoshops. But this was witnessed by  200.000 people.

Also false.  I just saw one about two weeks ago.  I've seen many in my short life.  And many many more moon halos (especially in winter).

Is this another "trads-making-trads-look-bad" thread?


Re: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - K3vinhood - 07-27-2011

(07-27-2011, 04:22 PM)Pheo Wrote:
(07-27-2011, 04:20 PM)Thomas Patron Wrote: That's false, actually most photos of sun halos are photoshops. But this was witnessed by  200.000 people.

Also false.  I just saw one about two weeks ago.  I've seen many in my short life.  And many many more moon halos (especially in winter).

Is this another "trads-making-trads-look-bad" thread?

Judging by that post being his first on the forum, yes.


Re: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - jovan66102 - 07-27-2011

(07-27-2011, 04:22 PM)Pheo Wrote:
(07-27-2011, 04:20 PM)Thomas Patron Wrote: That's false, actually most photos of sun halos are photoshops. But this was witnessed by  200.000 people.

Also false.  I just saw one about two weeks ago.  I've seen many in my short life.  And many many more moon halos (especially in winter).

Is this another "trads-making-trads-look-bad" thread?

Yeah, having seen quite a few with my own eyes, I don't think they were 'photoshopped'! :)


Re: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - SaintSophia - 07-27-2011

But even if its not miraculous, and brings people closer to their faith?... no harm, right


Re: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - jovan66102 - 07-27-2011

(07-27-2011, 04:27 PM)SaintSophia Wrote: But even if its not miraculous, and brings people closer to their faith?... no harm, right

IMHO, calling natural events 'miracles' is not going to bring anyone closer to the faith, in fact, probably quite the opposite. :)


Re: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - Thomas Patron - 07-27-2011

None of the sun halos photos that you post can be verified. Sorry the point is that most are photoshoped.
The only sun halo that is verified by thousands of people is this of the miracle of the sun at Fatima.



Re: The miracle of the sun Fatima 2011 - SaintSophia - 07-27-2011

They aren't declared miracles...or so I thought. I'm not saying declare one when it isn't just that if it moves people then its a good thing.