Vatican astronomer says if aliens exist, they may not need redemption
(11-16-2009, 08:42 AM)ggreg Wrote: If this race of beings had not fallen, then how would it be right and fitting for a female from a fallen race to be Queen of the Angels and Mother of the Incarnate God?

Presumeably Angels are higher in the hierarchy of creation than men, in as much as they are unfallen and unfettered by human bodies and all the other limitations of a physical existence, such as death.

Why should Mary get that supreme honour (Queen of the Angels) and not a member of their unfallen race?  Seems a little unjust to me.

Besides, is there as much as the vaguest shred of evidence for any life on any other planet?  Is not ALL of this based on the THEORY of evolution and the fact that there are a heck of a large number of stars in the visible universe.

In that sense I reject the entire thing.  Because I know what lies at the root of it.

Again, I don't really know if aliens exist.  And if alien life did exist, its also possible that there is no other rational life forms in the universe (and then its still us and angels).  However, for the sake of this question, I'm going to assume rational alien life exists.

First, I think you're looking at Mary privileges the wrong way.  Mary is not Queen of Heaven, because she is sinless.  She is Queen of Heaven, because she's the Mother of God (and that's also why she was preserved from sin in the first place).  Secondly, the nature of man was exalted because of the Incarnation.  Since the Word became flesh, we're now at a state infinitely superior to before the Fall.  Thus, in light of the Incarnation, Mary's status as Queen of Heaven makes sense.  She's the Morning Star of the form that the Savior assumed.  Thus, she's higher in the hierarchy of grace than even any unfallen creature (whether they be pure spirit or corporal).

In the Space Trilogy, Lewis specifically addressed where man fits in the hierarchy of rational beings.  In Out of the Silent Planet, the main character travels to Mars and encounters three species of rational creatures (each with a unique form).  Each species is unfallen, and they are regularly in communion with angels and God Himself ("walking with God").  The second book, Perelandra involves the creation of life on Venus.  God recently made rational life on Venus, and he sends the main character from the first book to the planet to try to act as a counter-tempter and prevent the the rational creatures (one species with the form of man) on that planet from falling to the temptation of the devil.  Since these rational creatures were created after our own planet's Fall, they only have the form of man, because it is God's own chosen form.  Thus, man still holds a prominent place in the hierarchy of creation, despite there being other rational creatures.  Its good fiction...

Messages In This Thread
Re: Vatican astronomer says if aliens exist, they may not need redemption - by Historian - 11-16-2009, 06:01 PM

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)