Do You Think the Holy Ghost Chose Pope Benedict XVI....

[Old Salt]

So, it's official now.

FE has fully converted into CAF.

I did not know that FE was in the catechumenate stage converting to the Catholic Church.

Apparently, the conversion to Conciliar Catholicism is almost complete.

Why do you bother here then?

Because it's one of those rare places where open and frank discussion of religious topics is allowed, if we overlook the ban on sedevacantism. Furthermore, there are still some fine Catholics around, although the place has been flooded by a brand of neo-catholicism (or "conservative catholicism") for a couple of years now.

There is no such thing as the labels you mention.
There are only Catholics and non-Catholics.

Don't be silly.

Why not just a simple Yes or No?  Stupid choices.

Agreed.  I'm not voting because I don't like being led to an explanation.

How is saying one is either a Catholic or a non-Catholic "silly"?
For one to be a Catholic one has to believe everything the Church proposes for our belief, everything.
If one does not believe everything that the Church proposes for belief, one is not a Catholic.
There are no in betweens or labels, in real life.