When was original sin removed from OT saints?
(07-20-2012, 08:38 AM)Melkite Wrote: Aquinas was wrong about the immaculate conception, he is wrong about this as well. 

We know he is wrong about the Immaculate Conception because it was infallibly stated so.  I suspect that St. Thomas holding a heterodox view on the IC was part of the reason that it was stated ex cathedra.

I know that you're not a big Thomist, Melkite, but this issue is not analogous and it is the case that, given things like Aeterni Patris, Catholics don't really have much a leg to stand on when arguing with Thomas where the Church has not also done so.

I think we can agree that Thomas doesn't state something lightly.  Do you have an equally thoughtful argument against the efficacy of circumcision? 

Messages In This Thread
Re: When was original sin removed from OT saints? - by Walty - 07-23-2012, 12:36 PM

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)