Women Priest Women Lie
#1
Let’s start with the first sentence of the WJLI news report: “Even though the Roman Catholic Church has a new pope, there’s no sign of change in letting women be priests.”

You might not like that opening sentence; it hints at the possibility that a new pope might have changed the perennial teaching of the Church on the impossibility of ordaining women to the priesthood. Still as it stands the sentence is accurate, and rightly conveys the fact—fact, I repeat—that women cannot be ordained as Catholic priests.

So now look at the headline on the same story: “Roman Catholic women priests ordained in Falls Church.” How could that be, if women can’t be ordained as priests? Which is true: the headline or the lead sentence? They can’t both be right.

Read on, and the confusion mounts. The ceremony took place at the First Christian Church. One of the women who claimed ordination is a chaplain at an Adventist hospital. Her husband is a Methodist, the story tells us, “but she said she couldn’t give up her Catholic faith.” Then, a few sentences later, we’re told that “the women taking part are automatically excommunicated.” So then she did give up her Catholic faith, didn’t she?

Fellow journalists, this really isn’t that hard. You can’t be a Catholic priest if you’re not a Catholic. Since the Catholic Church does not ordain women as priests, women who claim to be priests must belong to some other organization. You can argue against Catholic teaching, and can champion the cause of these women, if you like. But the principle of non-contradiction still applies.

http://www.catholicculture.org/commentar...cfm?id=606
Reply
#2
Not only was she excommunicated but every "Catholic" who participated knowingly in any way was also excommunicated.
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)