The Catholic Church forbids circumcision for any reason!

[AxxeArp]

I agree with you Austen.  It is these strange cultish pet issues of trads that makes me really take a step back and re-think whether I want to have any association with the Trad movement.

Vox, you might want to really take a step back from this crusade against circumcision and look at your own faults.  You allow a Sede priest to run free-reign, spouting all his slanders and heresies, on a forum where the target audience already has a disposition to sedevacantism.  To me that’s infinitely worse, and more obvious a fault, than some obscure idea about circumcision.