Hypothetical for Sedevacantists
#1
Imagine Francis by a miracle suddenly made a complete U-turn (ie. renounce V2, ban NO, reinstate TLM). Any speck of modernism is driven out. All during his Papacy.

In this hypothetical, would a sedevacantist cease being one solely based on Francis' actions? Or does something additional need to be done, such as another Vatican conclave being called? As I understand, most sedevacantists dont view the post-concilliar Popes as having started out as true Popes then falling, but rather having never occupied the Chair in the first place. 

I think a Francis U turn sounds like a sufficient enough recovery for the sedeprivationist, but Im not so sure about the sedevacantist.

Cheers
Gentle Star of ocean!
Portal of the sky!
Ever Virgin Mother
Of the Lord most High!

Shew thyself a Mother;
Offer him our sighs,
Who for us Incarnate
Did not thee despise.

Through the highest heaven,
To the Almighty Three,
Father, Son, and Spirit,
One same glory be. Amen
Reply
#2
Most sedevacantists I know, including myself would probably accept him. We believe that the post conciliar popes have generally been validly elected, but lost the papal authority due to heresy. Some might believe he would need to be re-ordained and consecrated as a bishop though.
Reply
#3
I'd love to see the Holy Father suddenly strutting around in the Papal Tiara, excommunicating Germans whenever one crosses his path.
[-] The following 3 users Like choosetowitness's post:
  • jovan66102, Lavenderson, Username1
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)